Logo image
Back
Sentencing Female Drug Offenders: Reexamining Racial and Ethnic Disparities
Journal article   Peer reviewed

Sentencing Female Drug Offenders: Reexamining Racial and Ethnic Disparities

Matthew S. Crow and Julie C. Kunselman
Women & criminal justice, Vol.19(3), pp.191-216
07/01/2009
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/08974450903001511
Web of Science ID: WOS:000210934000003

Metrics

56 Record Views
13 Times Cited - Web of Science

Abstract

This study analyzes the relationship between race/ethnicity and sentencing outcomes for female drug offenders in Florida. Grounded in the focal concerns perspective, the research examines whether, in the specific case of drug offenders, minority women are treated more harshly than White women. Interaction models are estimated to determine the influence of drug offense type on racial and ethnic sentencing disparities. Differences in sentencing outcomes are also examined following significant policy changes in the state. In general, the findings suggest that minority female drug offenders are disadvantaged at both the incarceration and sentence length decisions. It also appears that perceptions of dangerousness associated with female offenders' race/ethnicity and offense are incorporated into sentencing authorities' patterned responses. That is, the level of disparity between Black, Hispanic, and White females is conditioned by type of drug offense in the interaction models. The changes in sentencing policy also impact the role of race and ethnicity in sentencing decisions. By analyzing drug offenders exclusively, the current study clarifies the role of race in sentencing decisions for females. In contrast to prior research that examined all offense categories together, the current study suggests that for drug offenses, minority females may, in fact, be deemed more dangerous and culpable than White female drug offenders.

Details

Logo image