Logo image
Representation When Constituent Opinion and District Conditions Collide
Journal article   Peer reviewed

Representation When Constituent Opinion and District Conditions Collide

E. Scott Adler, Adam F. Cayton and John D. Griffin
Political research quarterly, Vol.71(3), pp.681-694
09/2018
Web of Science ID: WOS:000439606000014

Metrics

Abstract

Congress representation roll call votes vote choice district conditions Government Studies Political Science Public Opinion United States
When constituent opinion and district conditions point in two different directions, which factor is most influential for representatives who face important legislative roll calls? To address this question, we combine four types of data for the period from 2000 to 2012: key congressional roll call votes, district-level survey data, objective measures of district conditions, and other district demographics. We show (1) that material conditions in a district have an effect on legislative behavior independent of constituents' opinions; (2) that opinions are not always a better predictor of lawmaker decisions, compared to conditions; and (3) that whether lawmakers tend to reflect constituent opinions or district conditions is a function of the demographic makeup of their districts.

Details

Logo image