Logo image
Probabilistic vs. Binary Forecasting: The 53%–65% Rule
Journal article   Peer reviewed

Probabilistic vs. Binary Forecasting: The 53%–65% Rule

Kwan-Chen C Ma, Justin Davis and Kevin M Krieger
The journal of behavioral finance, Vol.online ahead of print, p.23
10/2026
Web of Science ID: WOS:001901727000001

Metrics

1 File views/ downloads
1 Record Views

Abstract

Binary Probability Forecasting 53%-65% Rule G41 G11 C53 D87 Finance Probability
When a forecaster converts a probability estimate into a binary prediction, information about conviction is discarded even though the underlying belief has not changed. This paper measures the economic value of that discarded information. Using stock market data, we find that at equal accuracy, probabilistic forecasts are more profitable than binary ones, and forecasts of out-performance magnitude more profitable than directional forecasts alone. Both advantages concentrate in a specific accuracy range — roughly 53% to 65% — that appears independently in research on human forecasting well outside financial markets, suggesting a general property of human judgment. How a forecast is expressed can matter more than how accurate it is.

Details

Logo image