Metrics
87 Record Views
Conference presentation
Mentor feedback characteristics that improve teacher skill development during a mixed reality simulated teaching experience
2022 Proceedings from MSERA Annual Meeting Little Rock, Arkansas 50th Anniversary Celebration
Mid-South Educational Research Association (MSERA) Annual Meeting, 50th Anniversary Celebration ( Little Rock, AR, 11/08/2022)
11/08/2022
Abstract
Background: Adequately preparing teachers for the demands of the classroom requires a clinical, skill based approached (Walkoe & Levin, 2018) with experiential deliberate practice (Pecore et. al., 2022). Obstacles to providing a clinical, skill-based approach, which include limited instructional activities, pedagogies, and repeated practice (Peercy & Troyan, 2017), can be addressed using mixed reality simulations that are skill based (Klassen et al., 2021). More importantly, focused formative feedback on direct skill development can be impactful in a focused mixed reality simulation experience. McDonald et al. (2014) and Davis et al. (2017) showed the benefits of practice opportunities that include feedback on skill development Additionally, feedback providing direction on skill improvement and appraising learners of progress (Kluger & DeNisi, 1996; Brookhart, 2017) advances growth (Natriello, 1987; Crooks, 1988; Black & Wiliam, 1998). The framework for investigating this study on characteristics of feedback relied mainly on Hattie and Timperley’s (2007) feedback categories of task, process, self-regulation, and self. Other feedback models to inform this study include Van den Bergh et al (2014) five categories of feedback, Brookhart’s (2017) description of feedback as comments, and Page et. al’s (2020) 10 elements of feedback. The research question guiding this work asked what characteristics of written feedback are helpful with skill development?
Methods: Using a naturalistic inquiry approach, this study examined written feedback provided to 20 preservice elementary education majors that volunteered to participate in a mixed reality simulation experience During the three-week experience, each participant practiced the skill of questioning by facilitating a class discussion on the water cycle with five avatars. Each participate completed three cycles of mixed reality simulations receiving mentor feedback throughout the process. Data collection consisted of mentor written feedback, participant iterative questioning, and mentor interview. Data analysis entailed an initial coding of written feedback as task oriented, process oriented, self-regulation, and self. Subcategories were identified from the works of Van den Bergh et al (2014), and Page et. al. (2020) and Chan & Luo (2021). These were then organized to further define the initial four categories. Overlaps were collapsed into a single subcategory where appropriate.
Preliminary Findings and Conclusions: Preliminary findings revealed that initial mentor feedback related primarily to task oriented feedback (i.e. “most of your questions were lower level meaning they had one correct response determined in advance”). As participants progressed through subsequent mixed reality simulations, mentor feedback became more process focused (i.e. “make sure you are asking students to explain their thinking and respond to other students.”) Self related feedback, encouragement from the mentor, consistently served to start all written feedback (i.e. “great job for your first lesson. I know it can be intimidating and awkward, but you did push through.”) Mentor feedback was determined to be a main factor in over 80% of the participants improving in questioning skill. This study provides insight into the characteristics of feedback that assist with advancing skill development growth of preservice teachers during a focused mixed reality simulation experience.
Details
- Title
- Mentor feedback characteristics that improve teacher skill development during a mixed reality simulated teaching experience
- Publication Details
- 2022 Proceedings from MSERA Annual Meeting Little Rock, Arkansas 50th Anniversary Celebration
- Resource Type
- Conference presentation
- Conference
- Mid-South Educational Research Association (MSERA) Annual Meeting, 50th Anniversary Celebration ( Little Rock, AR, 11/08/2022)
- Identifiers
- 99380497596206600
- Academic Unit
- School of Education; Instructional Design and Technology
- Language
- English